Best Training Collar For Stubborn Dogs – Top 8 Choices For 2023

Dogs are a big responsibility, and they need to be trained. Stubborn dogs are one of the most difficult types of dogs to train because they don’t want to listen. This has led many people to use training collars on their stubborn dogs in order to get them under control.

The best training collars for stubborn dogs come with many training features such as shocks or vibrations that can help your stubborn dog to become more obedient. 

There can be many benefits from using a training collar for dogs in the long run, and you won’t become a bad pet parent if using it.

This article will review the eight best training collars for stubborn dogs, so you can find one that’s right for your pup!

Best Training Collar For Stubborn Dogs: Top 3 Picks

Last update on 2024-12-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

8 Things To Consider Before Choosing The Best Training Collar For Stubborn Dogs – Buyer’s Guide

You may find that there are many factors you need to consider before choosing the best dog training collar, but the following things should get you started. 

Design

When choosing the right training collar for dogs, you want to look at the design and see whether it will be comfortable for your dog.

Also, you need to have in mind the purpose of the collar because there are three different designs for dog collars such as:

• anti-bark collars
• fence containment collars
• remote training collars for dogs

You should choose a collar design that mostly fits your dog’s behavior and specific needs. Now, if you have a large constant-barker dog, our well-written review on the best bark collars might help you.

Size

The size of your dog is another factor that you need to consider when getting the best training collar for stubborn dogs. 

Some collars are adjustable, but others don’t have this option so make sure they will fit and they are perfectly comfortable for your dog’s neck before purchasing.

As a good rule of thumb, you can find a perfect size for a collar if you put it on your dog’s neck and try to fit two fingers in it. If your fingers fit between the neck and the training collar, then the size is right.

Intensity (Shock levels)

When it comes to training collars for stubborn dogs, you want something that will deliver a shock level that will actually get your dog’s attention. This isn’t the same as hurting them or causing any pain, so don’t worry!

Most training collars for dogs come with warning vibrations or beeps before the actual shock that gives an unpleasant feel to your dog. However, if you think that the training collar can make your dog uncomfortable, you can set it at the lowest shock level at first, and then adjust it accordingly.

In terms of the shock levels, there is momentarily stimulation (short-term shock) and continuous stimulation (longer shock from 8-10 seconds).

Distance

The distance (or range) of training collars for dogs is another thing to consider. Some dogs need only a short-range collar, but others may have the ability to run away from you if they are not restricted. 

Also, the range can depend on your training area. If you have a large yard or farm, you should opt for a dog training collar that offers a higher range of coverage.

Most training collars for dogs are available in half to 1-mile range, while others can be from 3 to 4-mile range.

For additional options, dog GPS fence collar is also a great way to keep your furry friend safe while they are out in the yard.

Comfort

You also need to consider the level of comfort that your dog is going to have when they are wearing their training collar. If it isn’t comfortable, then there is a good chance that they won’t want to wear it, so choose one based on this criteria as well!

Another thing you should have in mind is the material of the collar. Most training collars are made of nylon material like collars for pitbull and for american bully. but some can be made out of leather. So choose the one that your dog feels more comfortable wearing.

Waterproof

Always check whether or not the training collar is waterproof. If it isn’t, then there might be a good chance that your dog will get wet while walking in the rain or on the beach. So this can damage the electronics inside and can cause some issues for their skin later on!

Battery

The battery life of your dog training system is essential, and you want to make sure that it is long enough. This way, there won’t be any issues with recharging them all the time, which can get annoying!

Our recommendation is to choose lithium-ion batteries that should last more than 50 hours and take 2 hours to recharge. Once changing should be enough for 2 weeks, with up to 3 hours daily training.

Price

The last thing you should consider when it comes to dog training collars is the price. The dog training system can be an expensive investment that can cost over $200. So you need to ensure that it won’t break your budget, especially if it isn’t worth it.

But at the same time, there are many affordable options available that may save you some money, but if they are cheap knock-offs, they may hurt your dog. So use your best judgment when considering the price.

With all of these factors in mind, choosing one of the best training collars for stubborn dogs won’t be so difficult anymore and will allow you to get started with training right away!

Now it’s time to take a look at the most popular options on the market right now.

Related Article: You might also consider buying a pet camera collar for your adorable pet to see what goes on their day.

8 Best Training Collars For Stubborn Dogs

A dog training collar can help you correct some of the most common problems that stubborn dogs have, like pulling on the leash, chewing everything they can get into their mouth or digging holes in your yard. 

With that being said, let’s review the best training collars for stubborn dogs.

SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers Review

This is one of the best great training collars that can be used for almost any type of dog (over 8 lbs) with neck size of up to 22 inches.

It has a solid range of 500 yards, which means you will never lose control over your pet again no matter where they go.

The device supports a system that allows you to train up to 3 dogs at once. So if you have more than one dog, this device might work perfectly for all of them! Note that you will need to buy additional collars, but not remotes (only one remote needed).

The stimulation modes include vibration, beep, and static mode. The static mode can be adjusted with 21 levels for momentary or continuous stimulation.

This training collar for stubborn dogs comes with a rechargeable lithium-ion battery that only takes 2 hours for charging and can last up to 70 hours of continuous use.

Last update on 2024-12-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers – Best Features

• 500-yard range. 
• Suitable for all kinds of breeds (over 8 lb). 
• Static stimulation with 21 adjustable levels.
• 3 different modes: vibration, beep, and static.
• Adjustable waterproof collar made out of quality material.
• Long-lasting lithium-ion battery that can recharge in just 120 minutes.
• Can be used to train up to 3 dogs at once – perfect for multiple dog owners.

SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers – Pros and Cons

Check Latest Price

PATPET Dog Training Collar Review

This training collar for stubborn dogs is great because it has a very long range of up to 1000 yards which is great for all dog breeds (from 8 to 120 lbs) that want to run around in your big yard or farm.

PATPET dog training system allows you to train up to 2 dogs with one remote (you just need to buy an additional collar).

There are 3 different training modes available with this model: vibration, beep, and static shock. You can also choose between momentary or continuous stimulation adjusted with 1-16 levels which is great because it gives you more control over the intensity of each correction. There is also a safety feature that prevents your dog from accidental static shock.

The collar itself is made out of quality waterproof material that will last a long time without degrading under any weather conditions.

The battery life on this device is impressive, lasting around 30 days for the collar and 60 days for the remote with just 2 hours of charging!

Last update on 2024-12-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

PATPET Dog Training Collar – Best Features

• Suitable for all kinds of breeds with neck sizes up to 27 inches.
• A long 1000-yard range so your pet won’t escape from home even if they wanted to. 
• 3 training modes: vibration, beep, static shock (16 levels).
• Security switch that prevents accidental shock.
• Suitable for simultaneously training 2 dogs (2 channels available).
• Momentary or continuous stimulation can be used for each training session.
• Quality waterproof material that will last a long time without degrading.
• Rechargeable battery that lasts around 30-60 days with just two hours of charging!

PATPET Dog Training Collar – Pros and Cons

Check Latest Price

Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar with Remote

The Pet Resolve dog training collar is one of the best training collars for stubborn dogs that comes with a new upgraded design and functionality.

This collar can be used on almost all small, medium, or large dogs (over 15 lbs) without any issues. It comes with a flexible waterproof material, which ensures comfortability at all times (even in water).

This device offers extremely long-range (3/4 mile), perfectly suitable for hunting dogs or dogs who like running away when they see other people walking down the street.

This dog training collar comes with another interesting feature which is removing the shock function, so you can only work with the vibration and beep mode. Also, you can use these functions all the time because there is no standby mode (the collar is always ready).

Last update on 2024-12-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar – Best Features

• Extra-long range of 3/4 mile (1312 yards) – perfect for hunting dogs 
• Waterproof design of the training collar – ensuring safety even if completely submerged in water.
• Removable shock mode – you can just use vibration and beep modes.
• Training up to 3 dogs simultaneously – you will just need to buy different collars.
• Available 10 modes for momentary or continuous shock.
• No standby mode – the collar is always active.
• Night mode – ideal for dark winter nights.
• Long lithium-ion battery life – can be fully charged just in 2 hours.

Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar Pros and Cons

Check Latest Price

Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar Review

This training collar for stubborn dogs is a simple solution that can help you “educate” your dog for the desired behavior within a range of 1/2 mile.

Like other similar models, the Educator e-collar comes with vibration and beep modes (but not a static shock mode). You also get an incredible 100 adjustable levels for safe stimulation.

The design itself is very simplistic, but ergonomic and intuitive to use.

The waterproof collar (made out of high-quality material) can be easily adjusted for neck sizes for up to 30 inches which makes it great for big dogs as well.

Last update on 2024-12-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar – Best Features

• Long-range of 1/2 mile (880 yards)
• Waterproof design that is very durable
• Adjustable collar size suitable for all kinds of dog breeds. 
• Rechargeable lithium-polymer battery that needs just two hours to recharge fully!
• No harsh static, only tapping sensation (vibration) with up to 100 levels    

Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar – Pros and Cons

Check Latest Price

PetSafe Rechargeable Bark Collar Review

PetSafe is a reputable company with over 30 years of tradition and quality. Their type of collar can safely put an end to your dog’s excessive barking by emitting a small static charge when it senses that they are barking too much. The static charge can be adjusted with 15 different levels.

What we like the most about this product is the bark-sensing technology. Once you set up the bark sensitivity level, there aren’t going to be any issues anymore because instead of just giving them a shock every time they bark, it will only do so when necessary.

The collar is designed with a quality waterproof material that allows dog training in any weather condition.

The battery life on this device is impressive, lasting around 40 days with just 2 hours of charging.

Last update on 2024-12-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

PetSafe Rechargeable Bark Collar – Best Features

• Suitable for all kinds of dogs (over 8 lb) with neck sizes up to 28 inches
• Static correction with 15 levels for automatic adjustment of the static charge
• Bark-sensing technology that recognizes your dog’s barking and avoids false correction
• Waterproof collar for training in rainy environments.
• Rechargeable lithium-ion battery that can last up to 40 days.

PetSafe Rechargeable Bark Collar – Pros and Cons

Check Latest Price

Garmin Delta XC Bundle – Dog Training Device Review

This training collar for stubborn dogs is another solid solution because it has a very long range of ½ mile.  This makes this device perfect if you have a huge farm where your dog can play without being constantly monitored.

Like other similar models, Garmin Delta XC Bundle comes with vibration and beep modes. Also, there is a shock mode with 18 levels of adjustable stimulation intensity (continuous and momentary) which is more than enough to train any breed easily.

The best part about this model is that the receiver fits all kinds of breeds, and you can train up to 3 dogs simultaneously (just you need to purchase additional collars)!

The design itself is intuitive and very easy to use – there are only 3 configuration buttons and an LCD display. 

The collar is made of high-quality waterproof material that can be easily adjusted for almost any neck size.

Last update on 2024-12-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Garmin Delta XC Bundle – Best Features

• Very long range of ½ mile (880 yards) perfect for large yards or farms.
• Controlled with vibration, beep, and static modes (static with 18 levels).
• Rugged waterproof design that is very durable in any kind of weather conditions.
• Adjustable collar size suitable for all kinds of dog breeds.
• Rechargeable lithium-ion battery that needs just 2 hours to recharge fully! 

Garmin Delta XC Bundle – Pros and Cons

Check Latest Price

Petrainer Shock Collar for Dogs Review

This training collar for stubborn dogs is specially designed to stop excessive barking and other unwanted behaviors. It operates within a range of 330 yards – which can be perfect for smaller backyards or parks.

The Petrainer shock collar comes with the standard vibrate and beep modes, as well as 100 adjustable levels of static stimulation which makes it great even for the biggest breeds that are hard to train! 

Another great thing about this model is its design – very easy to set up and intuitive without too many buttons on it (you will get used to the settings in no time).

The device uses rechargeable batteries that can be easily recharged. Just plug them into your computer via a USB port or any charging unit using a USB cable.

The collar is made out of durable materials that are waterproof, adjustable for neck sizes between 14 inches up to 25 inches which makes this model great even for smaller dogs as well!

Last update on 2024-12-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Petrainer Shock Collar – Best Features

• 330 yards of operating range
• 100 levels of static stimulation suitable even for the biggest breeds
• Intuitive design with only a few buttons on it – easy to use without too much hassle
• Waterproof material that can be adjusted from 14-inch neck size up to 25-inches
• Rechargeable batteries with 3-5 days lasting time after fully recharged via USB port

Petrainer Shock Collar – Pros and Cons

Check Latest Price

Pet Union PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training Shock Collar Review

The Pet Union training collar for dogs is one of the high-end models on our list because it has many great features for positive behavioral training, making it very popular among pet owners.

This dog training collar covers a solid range (up to 400 yards), perfect for training your dog around your house or in the park. 

The collar is designed with waterproof material that makes this device durable and suitable for any weather conditions.

Another amazing feature about the Pet Union PT0Z is its separate shock mode with 100 levels of adjustable intensity, and the other standard modes for vibration and tone warning. 

The device uses rechargeable batteries that have long-lasting life thanks to the power protection feature when not in use.

Last update on 2024-12-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Pet Union PT0Z Training Collar – Best Features

• Good range (400 yards)
• Waterproof design
• 100 customization levels for static stimulation and vibration
•  LCD remote
• 4 stimulation modes
• Power protection mode to save battery life

Pet Union PT0Z Training Collar – Pros and Cons

Check Latest Price

Benefits Of Using A Training Collar For Stubborn Dogs

There are a lot of benefits you get from using a training collar for stubborn dogs if needed, but we will focus on the main ones:

• Training your dog in a faster and more efficient way. 
• Stops excessive barking and other unwanted behaviors.
• Train dogs for any kind of activities like hunting or tracking.
• Great training tool even if it’s your first time using a shock collar.
• Prevent your dog from getting into trouble by giving you control over them.
• Safe to train even the biggest breeds without hurting them or making them scared! 

Disadvantages Of Using A Training Collar For Stubborn Dogs

Even though training collars for stubborn dogs are a great tool when it comes to dog training, there’re also some disadvantages that you should consider before investing in one:

• Having the wrong setting on your shock collar might hurt/scare your pet.
• Can be considered as negative reinforcement.
• It can ruin your relationship with your dog.

Where Should A Shock Collar Be Placed On A Dog?

This is probably one of the most important factors in the successful training of your dog with a shock collar. Many people get this simple step wrong and wonder why their pets won’t respond to the electric impulse.

The collar should be fitted around the dog’s neck, on the lower side, right behind the ears. Putting it here, you make sure the entire neck is covered by the shock collar. Don’t put it at the back of your dog’s head though, as this may hurt his ears.

To test whether it is placed correctly, you can give a light tug on the leash and see if it will activate.

If you are using a remote training device, keep in mind that the stimulation mechanism should be pressed directly against your dog’s skin. Make sure not to apply too much pressure though as this may cause discomfort.

By placing it correctly around your dog’s neck, it ensures better contact between the electric impulse and the skin. This area of the dog’s body has less loose skin and is also sensitive enough to feel the impulse’s effect.

The better the contact, the more likely your dog will respond to it and eventually learn to avoid the wrong behavior.

Placing it elsewhere will not only reduce the effectiveness of the training tool but can also lead to confusion and anxiety on your pet’s part.

For example, placing it on his back will confuse him because he won’t know why the unpleasant sensation is happening; putting it on his tail will scare him because he won’t be able to figure out what he did wrong.

You may think that if the collar is effective, then placing it anywhere will do; however, this goes against training principles that ensure the dog’s safety.

Putting it around his neck will motivate and encourage him to follow your commands because he trusts that you have the best intentions for him.

Remember to always use a best-rated shock collar as directed and make sure it is placed correctly on your dog’s neck before beginning his training. That way you are more likely to achieve the results you want and reduce any possible confusion on your pet’s part.

Although using a shock collar may sound like a harsh punishment, it works effectively because it gets your dog’s attention and helps him understand his mistakes. Once the collar is on correctly and comfortable for your dog, they barely notice it is there.

Once removed, your pet won’t have any unpleasant memories so he can enjoy being around you with no negative emotions.

FAQs About Using A Training Collar For Stubborn Dogs

Conclusion